3D, Graphene, New Age Board Design -Msg board thead saver
Posted: Sun Oct 13, 2013 9:03 am
Windaddiction: here's a neat idea http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/170 ... r?ref=live - Saturday October 12, 12:25AM
Geoffy: - windaddiction, some marketing misleading stuff in there. Board weighs same as mine, replaces EPS - expanded polystyrene foam core (petrochemical) with ABS - acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (worse petrochemical) core. Lots of other things I disliked and rubbed me badly about his marketing, but outright misleading there. Concept could work with some of the things being developed using new (not commercial) additive manufacturing though. - Saturday October 12, 9:16AM
Kus: ...why not use wood? I love the hollow wood Pasta approach. "We know this works because it is how wings have been constructed for the last century" except there's not usually a 200lb guy landing on a small portion of the wing after a 15' jump among other things. I agree you need the right board for your body type, sailing ability, wind strength, swell, place you sail...you don't need a fancy data collector to provide this opinion for you....plus all those things are fluid if you move around or progress at all. Overly simplistic in the most uebertechnical sense possible. - Saturday October 12, 9:35AM
Kus: on that train, Pasta: wanna build a custom quad WS board out of wood? At current $2500MRSP tags, this might be a cool, profitable addition to your furniture output - Saturday October 12, 9:42AM
Windaddiction: I still liek the idea of a 3d printed board.... too bad there isn't a pirnter big enoguh to do a whole board one piece! - Saturday October 12, 5:44PM
Geoffy: There are folks working on printing materials made from wood fiber and soy-based resins, still compromised IMHO. Real breakthrough will be in carbon fiber from lignin waste (see Weyerhaeuser/Zoltek research) printed with soy-based urethane resin. And pretty easy to make a 3D CNC printer big enough to do windsurfers/SUPs, still not best technology match I think. - Saturday October 12, 7:06PM
Gwind: WoW, possibilities are endless, 3 D printers are just in there infant stage. Very cool Mr. Data - Saturday October 12, 7:57PM
Voodmon: In the olden days of windsurfers with teak booms, teak dagger boards and a teak universal plug we pondered this conundrum, just like the ancient Hawaiian surf boards were made of wood, perhaps we are coming full circle here. - Saturday October 12, 9:28PM
Kayakdoc: Graphene: Even though my latest board (The Phillet Mignon) is EPS/carbon/epoxy and weighs less than 5 lbs. this will be a behemoth compared to the next generation of board construction materials. If 3D graphene ever becomes commercially available I am in. “As of 2009, graphene appears to be one of the strongest materials ever tested. Measurements have shown that graphene has a breaking strength over 100 times greater than a hypothetical steel film of the same (incredibly thin) thickness, with a tensile modulus (stiffness) of 1 TPa (150,000,000 psi). However, the process of separating it from graphite, where it occurs naturally, will require some technological development before it is economical enough to be used in industrial processes, though this may be changing soon. Graphene is very light, weighing only about 0.77 milligrams per square meter. The Nobel announcement illustrated this by saying that a 1 square meter graphene hammock would support a 4 kg cat but would weigh only as much as one of the cat's whiskers, at 0.77 mg (about 0.001% of the weight of 1 m2 of paper). Graphene paper or GP has recently been developed by a research department from the University of Technology Sydney by Guoxiu Wang, that can be processed, reshaped and reformed from its original raw material state.....Lead researcher Ali Reza Ranjbartoreh said: 'Not only is it lighter, stronger, harder and more flexible than steel, it is also a recyclable and sustainably manufacturable product that is eco-friendly and cost effective in its use.' Ranjbartoreh said the results would allow the development of lighter and stronger cars and planes that use less fuel, generate less pollution, are cheaper to run and ecologically sustainable. He said large aerospace companies have already started to replace metals with carbon fibres and carbon-based materials, and graphene paper with its incomparable mechanical properties would be the next material for them to explore.” Might be vaporware and research PR hokum, but this looks like the real thing. Graphene honeycomb with graphene skins. Super stiff, gossamer light and bullet proof strong. Eco friendly as well, maybe (I always take that statement with a pinch of salt). Boards and kites will be measured in picograms. - Saturday October 12, 10:07PM
Geoffy: Ahh, Phil - Theory and dreams, great stuff. Graphene is the new nano, miracle fund raising material, next step beyond single-walled nano-tubes. No matter the ultimate tensile strength/stiffness attainable, we will still be captive to stress transfer, compression, shear, and minimum skin thicknesses brought upon by other factors. Back in 1992 we were making spacecraft truss structures with pitch graphite fibers with modulus of 120msi, close to that of graphene you noted. Some weird and funky things happen when wall thicknesses get uber-thin and you try to have hard points and joints. By the way, beryllium and magnesium are wonder materials also (beryllium kind of tough to work as it's seriously toxic and probably get you on government hit lists, but Mg ???) Ahh to have the playground and be able to make toys of some of these things buried in our minds, will be great someday. - Saturday October 12, 10:59PM
Kayakdoc: Geoff; Maybe we can open a shop in Maui. I know the perfect place. - Saturday October 12, 11:31PM
Windaddiction: Wow what an awesome week ahead!! If anyone has not checked out kickstarter and is board look at soem of the projects! It almost feels like a revolution where regular people with awesome ideas can make it happen! And I can watch the videos through the firewall at work awesome! - Saturday October 12, 11:36PM
Thankgodiatepastafobreaky: hey Kus. so far I can turn a tree into a bed and into good chaching very quickly compared to designing, building, shaping and glassing a hollow board. But I'm still in the design stage. I am holding out on the foam. Almost everyone keeps telling me I will have to go to foam soon, but I'm not so sure. I need to work some flex into the design since something has to give, and not my ankles. Light and rigid is ok but light and slightly flexible is a bit better. I have an idea for ribs with some give.. we will see..So I can apply this method to a windsurfer I suppose...but I need to 3D print me so the other one of me can just go to baja. - Sunday October 13, 12:08AM
Thankgodiatepastafobreaky: My browser was only showing the latest post from Kus, which I responded to, and then once it appeared there was all this talk of space age materials making me feel like a cave man - ha ha ha. Isn't graphine lighter than air? Might aid in jumping? - Sunday October 13, 12:16AM
Thankgodiatepastafobreaky: nice work Doc.. my second board with fins and deckpads and wax weighs 7.5 lbs. - Sunday October 13, 12:18AM
Gnarf: i'd be interested in in hearing more about the glass jobs on both those boards like how many layers of what weight of cloth as i am in the middle of glassing a board and still havent made up my mind on how heavy to go. - Sunday October 13, 7:51AM
Thankgodiatepastafobreaky: hey eric, I used 3.7 oz bottom, 3.7 oz top with another 3.7 around foot areas over 1/8th inch cedar over ribs and air. The perimeter stringer provides much of the strength. If I was going to try foam I'd be inclined to use the Starboard method with a central carbon reinforced stringer. - Sunday October 13, 8:32AM
Geoffy: - windaddiction, some marketing misleading stuff in there. Board weighs same as mine, replaces EPS - expanded polystyrene foam core (petrochemical) with ABS - acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (worse petrochemical) core. Lots of other things I disliked and rubbed me badly about his marketing, but outright misleading there. Concept could work with some of the things being developed using new (not commercial) additive manufacturing though. - Saturday October 12, 9:16AM
Kus: ...why not use wood? I love the hollow wood Pasta approach. "We know this works because it is how wings have been constructed for the last century" except there's not usually a 200lb guy landing on a small portion of the wing after a 15' jump among other things. I agree you need the right board for your body type, sailing ability, wind strength, swell, place you sail...you don't need a fancy data collector to provide this opinion for you....plus all those things are fluid if you move around or progress at all. Overly simplistic in the most uebertechnical sense possible. - Saturday October 12, 9:35AM
Kus: on that train, Pasta: wanna build a custom quad WS board out of wood? At current $2500MRSP tags, this might be a cool, profitable addition to your furniture output - Saturday October 12, 9:42AM
Windaddiction: I still liek the idea of a 3d printed board.... too bad there isn't a pirnter big enoguh to do a whole board one piece! - Saturday October 12, 5:44PM
Geoffy: There are folks working on printing materials made from wood fiber and soy-based resins, still compromised IMHO. Real breakthrough will be in carbon fiber from lignin waste (see Weyerhaeuser/Zoltek research) printed with soy-based urethane resin. And pretty easy to make a 3D CNC printer big enough to do windsurfers/SUPs, still not best technology match I think. - Saturday October 12, 7:06PM
Gwind: WoW, possibilities are endless, 3 D printers are just in there infant stage. Very cool Mr. Data - Saturday October 12, 7:57PM
Voodmon: In the olden days of windsurfers with teak booms, teak dagger boards and a teak universal plug we pondered this conundrum, just like the ancient Hawaiian surf boards were made of wood, perhaps we are coming full circle here. - Saturday October 12, 9:28PM
Kayakdoc: Graphene: Even though my latest board (The Phillet Mignon) is EPS/carbon/epoxy and weighs less than 5 lbs. this will be a behemoth compared to the next generation of board construction materials. If 3D graphene ever becomes commercially available I am in. “As of 2009, graphene appears to be one of the strongest materials ever tested. Measurements have shown that graphene has a breaking strength over 100 times greater than a hypothetical steel film of the same (incredibly thin) thickness, with a tensile modulus (stiffness) of 1 TPa (150,000,000 psi). However, the process of separating it from graphite, where it occurs naturally, will require some technological development before it is economical enough to be used in industrial processes, though this may be changing soon. Graphene is very light, weighing only about 0.77 milligrams per square meter. The Nobel announcement illustrated this by saying that a 1 square meter graphene hammock would support a 4 kg cat but would weigh only as much as one of the cat's whiskers, at 0.77 mg (about 0.001% of the weight of 1 m2 of paper). Graphene paper or GP has recently been developed by a research department from the University of Technology Sydney by Guoxiu Wang, that can be processed, reshaped and reformed from its original raw material state.....Lead researcher Ali Reza Ranjbartoreh said: 'Not only is it lighter, stronger, harder and more flexible than steel, it is also a recyclable and sustainably manufacturable product that is eco-friendly and cost effective in its use.' Ranjbartoreh said the results would allow the development of lighter and stronger cars and planes that use less fuel, generate less pollution, are cheaper to run and ecologically sustainable. He said large aerospace companies have already started to replace metals with carbon fibres and carbon-based materials, and graphene paper with its incomparable mechanical properties would be the next material for them to explore.” Might be vaporware and research PR hokum, but this looks like the real thing. Graphene honeycomb with graphene skins. Super stiff, gossamer light and bullet proof strong. Eco friendly as well, maybe (I always take that statement with a pinch of salt). Boards and kites will be measured in picograms. - Saturday October 12, 10:07PM
Geoffy: Ahh, Phil - Theory and dreams, great stuff. Graphene is the new nano, miracle fund raising material, next step beyond single-walled nano-tubes. No matter the ultimate tensile strength/stiffness attainable, we will still be captive to stress transfer, compression, shear, and minimum skin thicknesses brought upon by other factors. Back in 1992 we were making spacecraft truss structures with pitch graphite fibers with modulus of 120msi, close to that of graphene you noted. Some weird and funky things happen when wall thicknesses get uber-thin and you try to have hard points and joints. By the way, beryllium and magnesium are wonder materials also (beryllium kind of tough to work as it's seriously toxic and probably get you on government hit lists, but Mg ???) Ahh to have the playground and be able to make toys of some of these things buried in our minds, will be great someday. - Saturday October 12, 10:59PM
Kayakdoc: Geoff; Maybe we can open a shop in Maui. I know the perfect place. - Saturday October 12, 11:31PM
Windaddiction: Wow what an awesome week ahead!! If anyone has not checked out kickstarter and is board look at soem of the projects! It almost feels like a revolution where regular people with awesome ideas can make it happen! And I can watch the videos through the firewall at work awesome! - Saturday October 12, 11:36PM
Thankgodiatepastafobreaky: hey Kus. so far I can turn a tree into a bed and into good chaching very quickly compared to designing, building, shaping and glassing a hollow board. But I'm still in the design stage. I am holding out on the foam. Almost everyone keeps telling me I will have to go to foam soon, but I'm not so sure. I need to work some flex into the design since something has to give, and not my ankles. Light and rigid is ok but light and slightly flexible is a bit better. I have an idea for ribs with some give.. we will see..So I can apply this method to a windsurfer I suppose...but I need to 3D print me so the other one of me can just go to baja. - Sunday October 13, 12:08AM
Thankgodiatepastafobreaky: My browser was only showing the latest post from Kus, which I responded to, and then once it appeared there was all this talk of space age materials making me feel like a cave man - ha ha ha. Isn't graphine lighter than air? Might aid in jumping? - Sunday October 13, 12:16AM
Thankgodiatepastafobreaky: nice work Doc.. my second board with fins and deckpads and wax weighs 7.5 lbs. - Sunday October 13, 12:18AM
Gnarf: i'd be interested in in hearing more about the glass jobs on both those boards like how many layers of what weight of cloth as i am in the middle of glassing a board and still havent made up my mind on how heavy to go. - Sunday October 13, 7:51AM
Thankgodiatepastafobreaky: hey eric, I used 3.7 oz bottom, 3.7 oz top with another 3.7 around foot areas over 1/8th inch cedar over ribs and air. The perimeter stringer provides much of the strength. If I was going to try foam I'd be inclined to use the Starboard method with a central carbon reinforced stringer. - Sunday October 13, 8:32AM